Challenges?

[tenjintenkai]

I will ask EVERY Top Spin player that reads this....
How many of you have SEEN a ball go out or was in and called out and for a split second you actually thought you would challenge it?

I know I have on more than one occasion....and I am not just saying that.

I second that, but i may became blind working on computers all day for years lol

I can even say it happened in the demo of TS4. There were 2 serves that looked to hit the line on clay and were judged out... also 2 forehands winner.

But again i may not be the "super human sight" reference... (eventhough i play on a huge plasma screen...)

[tenjintenkai]

I thought the whole point of computers is that they dont mistakes.

here is the irony: Don't they use computer for a Shot Spot to check if people made a mistake?

yeah? well go ask Roger what he thinks of that hawkeye crap credibility

[o Sinna o]

I will ask EVERY Top Spin player that reads this....
How many of you have SEEN a ball go out or was in and called out and for a split second you actually thought you would challenge it?

I know I have on more than one occasion....and I am not just saying that.

I second that, but i may became blind working on computers all day for years lol

I can even say it happened in the demo of TS4. There were 2 serves that looked to hit the line on clay and were judged out... also 2 forehands winner.

But again i may not be the "super human sight" reference... (eventhough i play on a huge plasma screen...)

lol

Three Sides about discussing a Challengesystem for TS4.

I am glad it's not in. It just makes no sense that the CPU simulates a mistake making CPU.

[djarvik]

Computers can be manipulated, sure, but they dont make mistakes Unless the "mistake" is pre-programmed.

Poor Roger.

[bluwaters]

^^ This.

I thought the whole point of computers is that they dont mistakes.

here is the irony: Don't they use computer for a Shot Spot to check if people made a mistake?

HaHaHa!!! Point taken

[Hawkeye Miihawk]

I thought the whole point of computers is that they dont mistakes.

here is the irony: Don't they use computer for a Shot Spot to check if people made a mistake?

yeah? well go ask Roger what he thinks of that hawkeye crap credibility

What!?!?!?

[tenjintenkai]

Roger, while not saying it clearly, has more or less implied that hawkeye wasnt trustable...

[JJ_DUBZ_87]

I've seen a couple of matches where a player hits a ball close to the line and Shot Spot says it was a foot wide or long and even the players are like "It definitely wasn't that far out..." ::awkward silence and glances:: and even the commentators are like "uh...well that ball was out..."

Even computers make errors...well, glitches...

[Hawkeye Miihawk]

Roger, while not saying it clearly, has more or less implied that hawkeye wasnt trustable...

hahaha lol I was just joking. My username is Hawkeye Miihawk. So when you said "hawkeye crap credibility", it was like you were referring to me. I knew what you were talking about all along .

[tenjintenkai]

oh ok my bad.... i thought your name was from a very cool character in One Piece, Takanome Mihawk

[Hawkeye Miihawk]

oh ok my bad.... i thought your name was from a very cool character in One Piece, Takanome Mihawk

lmao, it is. Dracule Hawkeye Mihawk from one piece. I made it Miihawk cause xbl wouldn't let me do Mihawk for some reason. It's just...you know since this thread is about hawkeye and I just happen to have hawkeye in my name...I practically came here looking for trouble .

[tenjintenkai]

ahah yeah i saw that... So i am looking forward to "Roronoa-zorro" your *ss

[bluwaters]

ahah yeah i saw that... So i am looking forward to "Roronoa-zorro" your *ss

Hahahahahhaa

[dahltennis]

Again someone please answer me, you say "the computer shouldn't be forced to make a mistake, yet so many of you think it should make more unforced errors (aka more mistakes...?!?!) Kinda funny to me.

[Jason Fernandes]

No as a Berdych fan I'm not fond of the device, especially not against Federer. Berdych got seriously **** due to hawkeye at the AO 2009 against Federer early in the 4th and also **** at 5-5 in the 3rd set TB in Miami last year, thankfully he won that though.