Challenges?

by **Coolhand Texas** » Thu, 03 Mar 2011 22:11

dahltennis wrote:Again someone please answer me, you say "the computer shouldn't be forced to make a mistake, yet so many of you think it should make more unforced errors (aka more mistakes...?!?!) Kinda funny to me.

ahh that is where you are wrong. It is your fault that the ball goes out "unforced errors". Since it was your timing that was off (early or late) it is you who made the unforced error, not the computer.

by **djarvik** » Thu, 03 Mar 2011 22:44

dahltennis wrote:Again someone please answer me, you say "the computer shouldn't be forced to make a mistake, yet so many of you think it should make more unforced errors (aka more mistakes...?!?!) Kinda funny to me.

look behind you! ...you just missed it :lol:

Not the computer should make mistakes - we should. We should be able too hold the button for to long and get an out :wink:

by **djarvik** » Thu, 03 Mar 2011 22:52

Coolhand Texas wrote:
dahltennis wrote:Again someone please answer me, you say "the computer shouldn't be forced to make a mistake, yet so many of you think it should make more unforced errors (aka more mistakes...?!?!) Kinda funny to me.

ahh that is where you are wrong. It is your fault that the ball goes out "unforced errors". Since it was your timing that was off (early or late) it is you who made the unforced error, not the computer.

...the computer just makes it possible. :wink:

Where in Challenges, the computer will make a mistake for you, just so you can challenge and correct his mistake

(sorry, missed your reply Coolhand)

by **dahltennis** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 01:42

Actually, you know what I just thought of? What if they put the animation of challenges in, but the player had no control... THAT would be the perfect solution! Like there were never actually bad calls, because the computer would know if it was wrong, but the animation of a challenge was included

for example say you hit a winner on the back of the line and it's called out, but then you're player automatically makes the challenge and it's overruled, I think that would be the best thing they could do in the ts series. Or even if you hit it out, but it's called in, then computer challenges. yes, they'd all be correct challenges, but I still feel it'd be a cool effect

by **VillaJ100** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 01:50

That could be kind of fun, after a very long rally with the crowd excitied or something. The ball could be JUST out, and alredy decided as out, yet not called 'out' by an umpire. The player automatically challenges, and its shown as 'out' on hawkeye. Might be more fun that just the computers line judge voice going "OUTTT", or even if it happens on a close to the line point, the decision will be always correct, but for that split second you as the player dont know which way its going to go....

by **tenjintenkai** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 07:56

dahltennis wrote:Actually, you know what I just thought of? What if they put the animation of challenges in, but the player had no control... THAT would be the perfect solution! Like there were never actually bad calls, because the computer would know if it was wrong, but the animation of a challenge was included for example say you hit a winner on the back of the line and it's called out, but then you're player automatically makes the challenge and it's overruled, I think that would be the best thing they could do in the ts series. Or even if you hit it out, but it's called in, then computer challenges. yes, they'd all be correct challenges, but I still feel it'd be a cool effect

Actually i think this idea is pretty cool

by **Rob ITST** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 08:05

How about they just play the Hawkeye animation on really close shots - the player wouldn't actually challenge it, but we get to see Hawkeye just like we do on TV.

by **tenjintenkai** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 08:18

another cool idea!

by **Coolhand Texas** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 09:18

Rob ITST wrote:How about they just play the Hawkeye animation on really close shots - the player wouldn't actually challenge it, but we get to see Hawkeye just like we do on TV.

Now that I like. Just to let us see how close the shot actually was.

Can always count Rob to come through :lol:

by **KluddKalle** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 09:46

+ 1 on that! In that form I could accept hawkeye in a TS game. Actually, now that I think about it it's something I really want!

by **VillaJ100** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 11:54

By the way yesterday I had definite challenge material. I hit a serve right on the line with fed called out, yet the ball mark on the clay had clipped the line... harsh.

by **tenjintenkai** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 11:56

told you so....
cpus are already starting to play with our minds

by **bluwaters** » Fri, 04 Mar 2011 12:48

Hahahahaha!!! Computers playing with our minds. I love it!!!

Rob that's a great idea about the hawkeye replay!!!
That should be something implemented into the TS Series...

Challenges?

Who is online